News

Did NAFTA Cost American Jobs? Maybe.

Donald Trump debate, Hillary Clinton debate, Hillary Clinton NAFTA

Donald Trump blasted NAFTA in the final Presidential debate. (Getty)

The North American Free Trade Agreement, commonly abbreviated as NAFTA, took center stage at the final Presidential debate October 19. Donald Trump pointed out that Hillary Clinton‘s husband Bill signed the agreement (though his predecessor George H.W. Bush negotiated it) and that she backed it as First Lady. He went on to say that the deal had been “a disaster” for America, causing significant job losses in areas like the Midwest (a notable set of swing states). Whether it’s true or not is a source of significant debate among economists, with opinions ranging in both directions.

The union-backed Economic Policy Institute called NAFTA a “failure” in a 2003 report. EPI noted that America’s trade balance with Mexico fell from a deficit of 40.8 percent to a 61.1 percent deficit. These deficits, according to EPI, account for 2.4 million manufacturing jobs. Trump has cited the EPI frequently in his campaign despite their open distaste for him.

A report from Trump’s alma mater, the Wharton School of Business at Penn, found mixed evidence for NAFTA’s success. The elimination of tariffs allowed American car manufacturers to move to Mexico, causing a drop in American automotive manufacturing jobs as a percentage of the continent’s jobs in that sector from 64.5 percent to 53.4 percent, a drop of 11.1 percent. Mexican automotive manufacturing is eventually expected to take a 25 percent share of the sector’s production and jobs. However, economists noted that NAFTA dropped Mexican immigration to America “nearly to a halt” and increased American jobs in design due to lower production costs. The report also noted that there was no guarantee the jobs would have stayed in America even without Mexico entering the market. The report ultimately concluded that NAFTA neither contributed to nor detracted from America’s economic growth in the ’90s.

Meanwhile, the conservative Heritage Foundation found a net increase of around 1 million jobs as a result of NAFTA. Heritage also found that wages from jobs supporting US exports paid 13 to 16 percent more than most other job sectors. Heritage quotes the US Trade Representative as saying that $1.2 million was traded per minute with NAFTA partners.

WATCH: Donald Trump Says “We Have Some Bad Hombres Here” During Debate

During the final presidential debate, Donald Trump described America's illegal immigration issue by saying that "we have some bad hombres here."

Click here to read more

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

2 comments

  1. Obviously NAFTA caused job losses. Anyone working at a factory during rises times knows that. The factory I worked at started shipping products to Mexico to be packaged for retail sale. Before NAFTA that never happened. Eventually that factory shut down along with every other factory in the area causing people to fall into poverty, crime, and drug abuse.

  2. THe point is and I don’t know why people bring it up, but Trump is right. Bill signed it. Trump has also expressed concerns about the BUshes the who campaign.