CBS 'Survivor' Winners at War logo
A “Survivor” winner has decided he is done with reality TV after his appearance on MTV’s “The Challenge” season 37. Find out why “Island of the Idols” sole survivor Tommy Sheehan says he’s done with reality TV for good.
Sheehan Said He’s Taking His Talents Back to the Classroom
Sheehan was the winner of season 39 of “Survivor,” “Island of the Idols,” defeating Dean Kowalski by a vote of eight to two. The only votes Sheehan did not receive were from Elizabeth Beisel and Aaron Meredith.
He went on to compete on MTV’s “The Challenge” season 37 alongside fellow “Survivor” castaways Michele Fitzgerald and Michaela Bradshaw. That season is currently airing, but Sheehan was removed from the game in the third episode due to a medical emergency — and that was it for his reality TV days. He recently told “Entertainment Weekly” when asked if he would play “Survivor” again that he has retired from reality TV.
“‘The Challenge’ and ‘Survivor’ were two of the coolest experiences I’ve ever done, especially ‘Survivor’ since I’ve been a fan of the show forever,” said Sheehan. “However, right now I’m taking my talents to the classroom. I love my life and career too much to leave again. This is where I officially announce my retirement from your television screens.”
If you’ll recall, prior to his stint on “Survivor,” Sheehan was a fourth-grade teacher in Long Beach, New York. He wrote in his “Survivor” bio that the accomplishment he is most proud of is “all the children’s lives I have changed teaching.” He added later, “I have the biggest heart. I love people and would do anything to help them, especially kids.”
It sounds like the classroom is right where he belongs.
Sheehan Wishes He Could Have Played ‘Survivor’ With Michele Fitzgerald
It’s too bad that Sheehan was medically evacuated from “The Challenge” before he could go very far in the game — and Fitzgerald was eliminated in the very next episode. Sheehan said in the “Entertainment Weekly” interview that he wishes he could have played “Survivor” with Fitzgerald.
“I would love to play [‘Survivor’] with Michele Fitzgerald. She is someone I know I can trust 1000 percent. Her social game is similar to mine, and I know we would have a blast playing together,” said Sheehan.
We wonder if Sheehan has been having weekly post-game discussions in his classroom while “The Challenge” is airing because he also told “Entertainment Weekly” that he did that when his season of “Survivor” aired.
“I loved my edit. I was able to hold my head high at school after each episode and teach my students that nice guys do finish first,” said Sheehan, adding, “Thursdays at school, the best part of the day was going over my gameplay with my class. I loved hearing their take on each episode and advice for what I had to win. It was a blast to relive my experience through their eyes.”
“The Challenge: Spies, Lies and Allies” airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on MTV. “Survivor” airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. Eastern and Pacific times on CBS. The 42nd season will air in the spring of 2022. Seasons 43 and 44 are casting now, so if you’ve always wanted to apply, now is your chance!
READ NEXT: ‘Survivor’ Castaways & Fans Slam Jeff Probst’s ‘Woke’ New Show