He is a Rutgers University graduate and even played on the school's soccer team. Coaching staff member Dan Donigan was actually going to offer Calafiore a job as he was a former captain on the team. According to NJ.com, Calafiore started in 49 of the 54 games he played in from 2007 through 2011. Instead, Calafiore ended up being on Big Brother. (Instagram/pr_calafiore)