Browns Trade Proposal Swaps Baker Mayfield for Former Super Bowl QB

Baker Mayfield

Getty Images Quarterback Baker Mayfield of the Cleveland Browns.

The Cleveland Browns have spent a ton of money to remain relevant amid the talent arms race in a stacked AFC, but with a suspension almost certainly on the way for Deshaun Watson, the team may need to dig even deeper into its proverbial pockets.

The likelihood that Watson misses a large chunk of the upcoming season changes the math under center in Cleveland, where a disgruntled Baker Mayfield and a middling Jacoby Brissett remain the top two alternate options on the depth chart.

Watson’s circumstances have opened a pathway for a QB swap with a new team, the San Francisco 49ers and one-time Super Bowl starter Jimmy Garoppolo, which could solve multiple problems now vexing the Browns organization.

The latest Browns news straight to your inbox! Subscribe to the Heavy on Browns newsletter here!

Mayfield For Garoppolo Trade Makes Sense if Watson Faces Long Suspension

Jimmy Garoppolo

Getty QB Jimmy Garoppolo of the San Francisco 49ers reacts during the third quarter against the Dallas Cowboys in the NFC Wild Card Playoff game at AT&T Stadium on January 16, 2022 in Arlington, Texas. (Photo by Tom Pennington/Getty Images)

A deal moving Mayfield for Garoppolo, which never made any sense for the Browns assuming Watson could start Week 1 or would miss only a few games, all of the sudden seems almost crucial to Cleveland’s success in 2022.

Mayfield is unlikely to ever take another snap in a Browns uniform after the team executed its trade for Watson. Mayfield asked out almost immediately following his replacement’s arrival, and recently came to a mutual agreement with the organization to sit out mandatory minicamp absent any financial penalty.

Translation: Mayfield has no interest in playing for the Browns, and Cleveland has no interest in Mayfield loitering anywhere near team activities.

It appeared that the organization simultaneously alienated Mayfield and destroyed any leverage it had in trade talks involving the quarterback upon its acquisition of Watson. A sticking point in negotiations around moving Mayfield in the months since has been his $18.9 million guaranteed salary in 2022, the lion’s share of which teams like the Carolina Panthers and Seattle Seahawks have demanded the Browns pay as part of any deal.

While Cleveland remains unlikely to pay for another team to take the quarterback off their hands, the Browns are now far more likely to deal Mayfield in return for a quarterback who can bridge the gap until Watson returns — even if that player is more expensive than Mayfield will be.

Garoppolo has a cap hit of $26.4 million this season, roughly $7.5 million more than Mayfield.

Browns Solve Two Problems at Once Trading Mayfield For Garoppolo

Getty ImagesQuarterback Baker Mayfield of the Cleveland Browns.

The 49ers have committed to second-year signal caller Trey Lance as their quarterback of the future and have been shopping Garoppolo to potential trade partners across the NFL for months.

San Francisco will need a backup for Lance, but Garoppolo is an expensive option in that regard. Mayfield would be, too, though considerably less pricey. He would also put to bed any QB controversy involving Garoppolo, who has led the Niners to two NFC Championship Games and a Super Bowl over the last three seasons.

On the Browns’ side of a potential deal, it would cost more to bring in Garoppolo than to keep Mayfield, but by doing so Cleveland can buy an effective QB insurance policy behind Watson and solve its Mayfield conundrum in one fell swoop.

The one potential hitch in a plan to trade for Garoppolo is the hitch in his throwing shoulder. He sustained the injury during the Niners’ Wildcard Weekend win over the Dallas Cowboys and underwent surgery to repair the damage in early March.

Garoppolo also suffered a thumb injury to his throwing hand late last year, though he is expected to be at full strength when the regular season begins in September.

Read More
Comment Here
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Anthony Hester
Anthony Hester
1 month ago

This trade makes too much sense. It effectively eats up all of Cleveland’s cap space while freeing up cap space for the 49ers. However, the Browns may have to trade, or worse, cut a veteran prior to the final roster cut to reach the cap. Here is the major hiccup to this trade. The Browns are set to win with the right quarterback. Andrew Berry must be wondering what happens if he brings in Garoppolo and he takes the Browns to the Superbowl. You cannot have two QB’s on the roster the following year. He would have to trade Garoppolo and keep Watson. It would give Garoppolo a year to audition and prove he is healthy and in an inevitable trade, Cleveland might recoup some much needed draft picks.

Dave Hook
Dave Hook
1 month ago

Not the stupidest thing I’ve heard but damn close. With all the money San Francisco has invested elsewhere, there is no way they are taking on Mayfield’s contract just to back up Lance. This story is nothing but ill-conceived wishful thinking. Just because Cleveland’s front office is filled with morons doesn’t mean San Francisco’s is.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x