Jameis Winston vs. Marcus Mariota: Who’s Better?

Jameis Winston is undefeated in his Florida State career. (Getty)

Jameis Winston is undefeated in his Florida State career. (Getty)

For only the third time in college football history, two Heisman Trophy winners will face each other in a game. And what a big game it is.

Newest honoree Marcus Mariota leads his No. 3 Oregon Ducks (12-1) against 2013 winner Jameis Winston and the 3rd-ranked Florida State Seminoles (13-0) in Thursday’s Rose Bowl at 5 p.m. Eastern. It’s the first semifinal of the inaugural College Football Playoffs.

The veteran signal-callers play in vastly different offenses, but both piled up the numbers.

Here’s the rundown on Winston and Mariota:


The Jameis Winston Scouting Report

2014 Official Highlights | FSU QB Jameis WinstonJameis Winston, last year's Heisman Trophy winner, remains unbeaten during his time as Florida State's quarterback. Winston ended the 2014 season completing 276 of 422 passes for 3,559 yards and 27 total touchdowns. Take a look back at some of his most memorable moments, as FSU prepares to take on Oregon in the Rose Bowl.…2014-12-17T23:41:33.000Z

The Numbers

Class: Sophomore

Height: 6’4″

Weight: 230

Season Stats Passing: 276-for-422 (65.4%); 3,559 yards; 24 TDs; 17 INTs; 147.0 rating; 15 sacks

Rushing: 50 carries, 82 yards, 3 TDs


Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths: Rocket arm; Size; Athleticism; Play-making ability; Big-game experience

Weaknesses: Sometimes sloppy with the football; off-the-field issues


The Lowdown

Winston took a small step back this season after putting up 40 touchdowns vs. 10 interceptions in his Heisman-winning 2013. He did throw for 27 scores in 2014, but his INT total rose to 17. Winston lost his 2 top receiving targets (Kelvin Benjamin and Kenny Shaw) and the No. 1 rusher (Devonta Freeman) from last year’s National Championship team, so that had to factor in. And it’s hard to imagine his rather lengthy list of off-the-field problems didn’t get into his head at least a little, though that can’t be proven.

Winston and Florida State got a reputation for being slow starters, but turning it on when they needed to. Either way, FSU did in fact turn it on as the Seminoles are undefeated again. In fact, Winston hasn’t lost since he’s stepped foot in Tallahassee. The guy just wins.


The Marcus Mariota Scouting Report

Marcus Mariota 2014 Highlights |1080p HD2014-09-20T16:55:25.000Z

The Numbers

Class: Redshirt Junior

Height: 6’4″

Weight: 219

Season Stats Passing: 254-for-372 (68.3%); 3,783 yards; 38 TDs; 2 INTs; 186.3 rating; 29 sacks

Rushing: 117 carries, 669 yards, 14 TDs


Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths: Athleticism; Play-making ability; Experience; Accurate, efficient passer; Quick release

Weaknesses: Needs to improve pocket passing; Runs too quickly when receivers are covered


The Lowdown

Numbers-wise, they don’t get much better than Mariota. The 53 total touchdowns vs. 2 interceptions are head-shakingly amazing. He makes sound decisions, which turn into big plays, which become points. The Heisman winner is a perfect fit for Oregon’s offense and the 3 years of experience is a huge plus. Finding major holes in Mariota’s game is not easy.

He doesn’t have the most powerful arm, but he does have a lightning quick release and gets the ball to his receivers on time. Mariota’s weapons aren’t exactly household names and much of that has to do with his ability to spread the ball around so effectively. And his open-field running skills are way above-average for a QB.


The Verdict

Both Winston and Mariota are great college quarterbacks. The fact they play 2 contrasting styles in 2 different offenses makes this a tough choice.

Winston hasn’t lost in an FSU uniform and knows how to win the close games. He doesn’t get enough credit for that. Mariota has mostly been in games decided by halftime.

But here’s why Mariota is the better quarterback right now: he lost his top targets from a year and the offense actually got better in 2014 with mostly new weapons. Winston lost his big guns and he took a step back this season. Mariota makes everyone better.

You could argue it’s Oregon’s offensive system that helps Mariota. And it does a bit (but, really, what coach puts a QB in a system he will fail in?). But let’s not forget a lot of the quarterback position is cerebral. And Mariota knows his offense better and makes better decisions than Winston does.

But we can revisit this next season, when both are playing on Sundays.