FanDuel Daily Fantasy Baseball: Best Picks for May 5

Giants catcher Buster Posey has been at his best vs. the Padres. (Getty)

Giants catcher Buster Posey has been at his best vs. the Padres. (Getty)

A month into the season and we’re beginning to see a few trends. The baseball season is long an

– The once-potent Phillies and Rangers can no longer hit.
– The once-pathetic A’s and Padres can.
Nelson Cruz is the best power hitter in the game. Not even spacious Safeco Field is a match for his pop. Only an injury (knock on wood) will slow him.
– Load up on hitters facing Colorado; that pitching staff is currently atrocious.
– No shortstops can hit anymore.
– Pirates OF Andrew McCutchen will break out soon. Though I don’t believe the same can be said for Angels 1B Albert Pujols.

There’s a full schedule of games in the majors on Cinco de Mayo – all night starts – so you have the entire player pool to work with.

FanDuel uses the following parameters: You get a $35,000 cap to spend on 9 players – 1 pitcher, 1 catcher, 1 first baseman, 1 second baseman, 1 shortstop, 1 third baseman and 3 outfielders.

You can find the FanDuel scoring key at the bottom of the post.

Interested in branching out beyond baseball? DraftKings is now offering contests in golf, soccer, MMA — and even the World Series of Poker.

Sign up for DraftKings and get a 100 percent deposit bonus up to $600.

Here are the best FanDuel lineup picks for May 5:




Shelby Miller, Braves, $8,700, vs. Phillies

At 3-1 with a 2.17 ERA, trading for Miller has definitely been worth it for the Braves. And with the Phillies bringing their almost-league worst offense to Atlanta, it should be Miller Time for at least another start.


Buster Posey, Giants, $3,500, vs. Padres

A recent hot streak has got Posey’s average up 30 points. I foresee that climbing a bit more Tuesday evening when the part-time catcher/1B faces the Padres’ Andrew Cashner. Posey is 9 for 17 with a couple of home runs vs. right-hander.

First Base



Eric Hosmer, Royals, $3,600, vs. Indians

When I saw Hosmer was 6 for 12 with a homer vs. Indians pitcher Danny Salazar, he immediately joined the short list of potential first base FanDuel plays for me. Then I see Hosmer hit .309 vs. Cleveland in 2014 and .385 this year, and the decision to use Hosmer was pretty simple.

Second Base



Jason Kipnis, Indians, $3,600, at Royals

Kipnis is hot, as in 8 for his last 12 with 2 homers hot. Add in his career .333 average vs. Royals starter Jason Vargas and you have your second baseman for the day.




Andrelton Simmons, Braves, $2,500, vs. Phillies

Shortstop is hands-down the toughest position to get production out of – nobody is hitting. Only Jed Lowrie of the Astros averages more than 3 fantasy points per game and he’s on the DL. Simmons works for Tuesday as he’s 6 for 14 with 5 runs scored in 4 games this month. And he’s cheap.

Third Base

Todd Frazier, Reds, $3,700, at Pirates

I said it the other day, and I’ll say it again; it’s practically all or nothing with Frazier. He has legitimate home run power, but he can also stink the joint up. I’m leaning toward the former as he faces Jeff Locke and the Pirates. Frazier is batting .400 vs. Locke and drilled 7 homers against the Bucs staff in 2014.


The Rays' David DeJesus. (Getty)

The Rays’ David DeJesus. (Getty)

Matt Kemp, Padres, $3,700, at Giants

Kemp’s bat has been quiet lately, but perhaps tonight’s visit from the Giants and starter Ryan Vogelsong is what he needs. Kemp is 12 for 32 (.375) with a homer and 7 RBIs vs. the righty.

Matt Holliday, Cardinals, $3,400, vs. Cubs

Holliday is one of my FanDuel favorites. Not only is he inexpensive, but he’s productive. His power has been absent, but he’s homered twice in 2 at-bats vs. Cubs starter Kyle Kendricks.

David DeJesus, Rays, $2,200, vs. Red Sox

Here’s the potential gem of the day. With Desmond Jennings on the DL, DeJesus will get more at-bats. And today’s the day you want DeJesus in there. He’s batting .364 vs. Red Sox starter Rick Porcello, who is clearly struggling. I needed a very cheap player and DeJesus fits perfectly into that role.

Total Lineup Salary: $34,900 of an allotted $35,000

Each day, we’ll give you the rundown of who to pick for a winning lineup, so stay with us the entire season.

FanDuel Scoring

Hitters Scoring:

Single = +1 points
Double = +2 points
Triple = +3 points
Home Run = +4 points
Run Batted In = +1 points
Run = +1 points
Base on Balls = +1 points
Hit By Pitch = +1 points
Stolen Base = +2 points
Out = -.25 points

Pitchers Scoring:

Inning Pitched = +1 points (fractional scoring per out)
Strike Out = +1 points
Win = +4 points
Earned Run Allowed = -1 points

DraftKings Now Has Fantasy Golf, Soccer, MMA & Poker

Interested in branching out beyond baseball? DraftKings offers a handful of other sports in season now like Golf, NBA, MMA and Soccer. NFL, College Football & Basketball, and NHL will be available when those seasons begin.


The NBA has reached the playoffs, but you can still play daily fantasy basketball. Get what you need to know about daily fantasy basketball at


Play fantasy golf each weekend as the PGA Tour is in full swing. Turn $20 into $1 million with DraftKings’ Millionaire Maker PGA Tour contest. The $2.5 million prize contest starts is for the U.S. Open, which starts June 18.


DraftKings offers contests from the MLS and EPL. Find out more about fantasy soccer over at


Participate in fantasy MMA with UFC events. Head over to DraftKings to learn more about fantasy MMA.

Sign up for DraftKings and get a 100 percent deposit bonus up to $600.

Comment Here
Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x