Ex-DWTS Pros Top Fans’ List of Tyra Replacements

Allison Holker and Stephen "tWitch" Boss

Getty Allison Holker and Stephen "tWitch" Boss

A new report says that “Dancing With the Stars” executives are looking to replace Tyra Banks as host amid the falling ratings, according to The Sun. Fans have replacement ideas all ready to go and they include several former professional dancers and alumni from the show.

Here are the top choices from a couple of different Reddit threads and how we think they stack up.

Allison Holker & Stephen ‘tWitch’ Boss

tWitch and Allison Holker with Lindsey Stirling on DWTSMacey Stars of Dance performance on Dancing with the Stars by Twitch and Allison Holker with Lindsey Stirling on Violin.2013-05-01T06:03:03Z

This one has gotten a lot of attention on Reddit. The married couple with three children met on “So You Think You Can Dance” and Allison went on to be a pro partner on “Dancing With the Stars” for four seasons (19-21 and 23). Plus, Allison has hosting experience HGTV’s “Design Star Next Gen” and “Disney’s Fairy Tale Weddings.” And tWitch is no slouch in that department — he has been the on-stage DJ for “The Ellen DeGeneres Show” for over 500 episodes where he also eventually became an executive producer on the show. He also hosts “Clash of the Cover Bands” for E! and has been tapped to host “The Real Dirty Dancing” on FOX, so they definitely have the TV cred and the dancing cred covered. We think they’d be great.

Fans on Reddit love this suggestion. One wrote, “Wait I love them both and never even thought of them hosting but that would be so perfect.”

Another wrote, “When they’ve been together on ‘Ellen’ and when he guested on ‘Design Star’ they bounce off each other very naturally. And they both are dancers so they can talk and walk the talk. Great, great, great suggestion!!!!”

“Love this. They have such good, chill energy and I think would be able to connect with the dancers while not making it all about them,” wrote a third fan.

Mario Lopez & Jeannie Mai

DWTS 304: Karina and Mario (Paso Doble)Karina Smirnoff and Mario Lopez dance the Paso Doble in the third season of ABC's Dancing with the Stars. Costumes designed by Randall Christensen. randalldesigns.net2017-10-25T22:08:04Z

Another popular suggestion was TV personalities Mario Lopez and Jeannie Mai. Mario has been a host at “Access Hollywood” since 2019 and before that was at “Entertainment Tonight” for 15 years. Jeannie has been a co-host on “The Real” since its inception in 2013 and has also hosted for “Entertainment Tonight” and “Holey Moley.”

Plus, they are both “Dancing With the Stars” alums. Mario competed on season three of the show with Karina Smirnoff, finishing in second place. Jeannie competed on season 29 with Brandon Armstrong before having to withdraw because of a medical emergency. They could be really good, they definitely have a lot of hosting experience.

Kym Johnson Herjavec & Anna Trebunskaya Also Got Some Votes

DWTS All Access Live – co-host – Kym Johnson-Herjavec2016 11 22 Highlights of Kym on All Access2016-11-23T14:19:24Z

Two former pro dancers who also received shout-outs are Kym Johnson Herjavec and Anna Trebunskaya. Kym was a pro on “Dancing With the Stars” on and off from season three until season 24; she is now married to her partner from season 20, Robert Herjavec. Kym also guest-hosted “Dancing With the Stars” when Erin Andrews took a brief absence after her now-husband’s nephew died and briefly hosted a “Dancing With the Stars” podcast in 2019.

Anna Trebunskaya was a pro on and off from season two through season 21. Fans like that she knows the show and they think she would “bounce off a co-host well.” We really enjoyed Anna’s live critiques of “Dancing With the Stars” season 30, so she might be a great choice.

Other pros mentioned include Karina Smirnoff and Lacey Schwimmer.

Alfonso Ribeiro Is A Divisive Choice

VideoVideo related to ex-dwts pros top fans’ list of tyra replacements2021-12-03T11:32:38-05:00

“Dancing With the Stars” winner Alfonso Ribeiro (he won season 19 with pro partner Witney Carson) has been mentioned several times. A lot of fans think he would be great and he does have hosting experience — funnily enough, he took over for former “Dancing With the Stars” host Tom Bergeron when Tom left “America’s Funniest Videos.”

But some fans think he’s too much — one fan even likened him to Tyra Banks, writing, “Alfonso is truly the most annoying human being to grace these screens, second time Tyra lol if he became host I don’t know how I would cope.”

Another wrote, “I’d stay away from former contestants solely based on them probably trying to make things about themselves and their experiences cough Alfonso cough.”

Other past contestants mentioned include Leah Remini, Joey Fatone, and Danica McKellar.

What About the Houghs?

VideoVideo related to ex-dwts pros top fans’ list of tyra replacements2021-12-03T11:32:38-05:00

Fans are split about if they’d want Derek or Julianne Hough to host. Some fans are calling for them to be the hosts together, but one fan wrote of that idea, “I like them as separate entities, them together maybe too much of… Hough energy for me lol.”

And another fan doesn’t want to lose Derek as a judge, writing, “I’m torn because you’re absolutely right [about Derek], but I also think he’s such a good judge,” to which another commenter replied, “He brings a great balance of constructive criticism and support to the panel. But a great host could play off the judges and support the dancers on the floor too!”

One user thinks Derek is better as a judge and actually long-time judge Carrie Ann Inaba would be better as a host. But the Houghs do have hosting experience — they have hosted holiday specials for ABC and NBC for several years.

“Dancing With the Stars” has not yet been renewed for season 31. If it is renewed, it will return in September 2022.

READ NEXT: DWTS Pros Open Up About Body-Shaming From Fans

Read More
Comment Here
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Felicia Tierney
Felicia Tierney
1 month ago

I could care less what color Tyra is…she could be green for all I care. She was ABSOLUTELY the WORST POSSIBLE choice as a host. As soon as they announced her I said, “I’m done”.

Everything has to be about her and that’s not what that job is about!

They had the chance to bring in a DANCER of color if they wanted to diversify the ballroom. Tyra was a stunt and a BAD ONE.

I think Allyson and Twitch would be the perfect duo as hosts.

Jeselle Sottile
Jeselle Sottile
1 month ago

@tonya gaiters sorry you feel that way, but don’t be so quick to play the race card. This decision has nothing to do with racism and more to do with the fact that Tyra is just a terrible host, period. It’s why she got fired from America’s Got Talent, and personally, I love her (also Black) replacement, Terry Crews. It’s clearly not “a few so called fans,” feeling like this, as rating have dropped dramatically as it has with any other project she’s been on. She’s not personable or host-material. If you read the article, the producers have offered a few replacements in mind, including 2 past Black contestants, one of which was a DWTS winner. Probably better to go with someone who’s been on the show, to understand and talk about a performance. Tyra is in that ANTM mentality, coming out every week talking about herself and her outfits and less about the contestants. It gets annoying that her costume changes are more dramatic than the contestants. I’m going to assume you don’t watch the show because you would’ve known their past 2 white hosts (Tom Bergeron and Erin Andrews) who were also fired. What it comes down to, is they’re looking for someone personable, respectful and fun. Not someone who talks over the judges thinking she’s a judge. Part of the reason why racism continues, is because there are people who like to play that card at the drop of a hat, and project a false narrative that has nothing to do with it in the first place. Sit down and watch the show to understand or take a seat. No one is here for your unnecessary grievances, so keep that energy going for places where it really counts, where inequality IS real. But this, here? Ain’t it.

Tonya Gaiters
Tonya Gaiters
1 month ago

This is why racism continues, because it’s supported. a few so-called fans don’t like the “Black person leading so they rant and rave and it all gets changed. If Heidi Klum or Gizelle was hosting there would be nothing said.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x