The New York Yankees haven’t even wrapped up the regular season, but the rumor mill is already cranking up in the Bronx. Bo Bichette, the Toronto Blue Jays shortstop set to hit free agency, is suddenly being linked to pinstripes. The buzz has Yankees fans salivating at the thought.
Insider Connects Yankees to Bichette
Toronto finds itself in a tricky position with Bichette. On one hand, the 27-year-old is one of the best offensive shortstops in the game. He’s the only impending free agent shortstop who can boast multiple All-Star appearances, and his track record at the plate makes him one of the most attractive bats available this winter. On the other hand, his defensive metrics—namely, his negative-13 outs above average this season—rank dead last at his position.
That combination of elite offense and defensive questions is why insiders believe his next team might not lock him in at shortstop for the long haul. According to MLB.com’s Keegan Matheson, the Yankees are a team to watch. “Position is going to determine the field—or perhaps even expand it—but I’d roll the Yankees in,” Matheson wrote. “Even if he’s signed as a second baseman or third baseman, Bichette is a bat that fits in any lineup.”
National MLB insider Mark Feinsand echoed that take, noting that the Yankees’ infield picture is fluid and could shift to make room. “The Anthony Volpe era could be ending as we speak,” Feinsand wrote. “The Yankees have second base (Jazz Chisholm Jr.) and third base (Ryan McMahon) locked up for the next year or two, so they would have to view Bichette as a shortstop for 2026 and figure it out after that.”
In other words, there’s a clear path for Bichette to start at shortstop next year before transitioning to another role. That would also allow top prospect George Lombard Jr. to eventually slide into the position, while Bichette’s bat keeps him locked into the heart of the lineup.
A Familiar Yankees Playbook
If this all sounds familiar, that’s because it is. For decades, the Yankees have frustrated their American League East rivals by prying away marquee names. Whether it was Johnny Damon leaving the Red Sox for the Bronx or Gerrit Cole choosing New York in free agency after years of speculation, the Yankees have a long history of turning rumors into reality.
Adding Bichette would not only bolster their lineup but also deal a crushing blow to Toronto, a team desperately trying to keep pace in the division. With Bichette’s contract status unresolved, the Yankees’ deep pockets and knack for swooping in late make them an ever-present threat.
The Yankees already boast star power across their roster, but their offense has shown inconsistent performance. Slotting Bichette into the two-hole ahead of Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton—or perhaps even using him to lengthen the order in the middle—would give manager Aaron Boone one of the most dangerous lineups in the sport.
For fans, the thought of Bichette trading in his Blue Jays blue for Yankees pinstripes is tantalizing. The potential to weaken a rival while strengthening the Bronx Bombers’ chances of another October run is exactly the kind of offseason storyline that keeps the Yankees at the center of baseball’s universe.
Insiders caution that the sweepstakes are far from decided, but history has shown the Yankees rarely sit idly by when a prime star becomes available. If Bichette hits the open market, expect the Bronx to be buzzing louder than ever.
Yankees Could Steal Rival’s Star Shortstop in Stunning Twist