Former NFL Exec Reveals Steelers’ Likely Decision on Tyrann Mathieu

Getty Tyrann Mathieu runs with the ball after intercepting a pass.

Calls by fans for the Pittsburgh Steelers to ink veteran defensive back Tyrann Mathieu have been loud and proud since before the March 16 start of NFL free agency. Pittsburgh is one starter short at the safety position, and despite Steelers Nation’s pleas, Mathieu is still on the market.

According to NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport, the three-time All-Pro isn’t in a hurry to cement his future.

“I don’t get the sense that he’s in a rush at all,” Rapoport told Pat McAfee on March 25. “Like every year, there are a couple of free agents, who kind of just linger out there and wait for maybe the draft. Maybe if a team needs a safety, needs a leader, maybe they don’t get what they wanted in the draft, they come get him. I could see Honey Badger being out there for a while.”

ALL the latest Steelers news straight to your inbox! Join the Heavy on Steelers newsletter here!

Join Heavy on Steelers!

Rapoport suggests that Mathieu, 29, is selective because the offers he’s been getting don’t jive with his perceived worth.

“The really good ones who know their value will just hang out and wait,” Rapoport continued. “It doesn’t always work out, but a lot of times it does. Because if you’re a great player, you have all the leverage. You’re a great player. You just have to be patient and hang with it a little bit.”


Money Talks

It essentially comes down to money, as it almost always does in life. The Steelers aren’t firmly in a financial position to be players in the Mathieu sweepstakes. Why? They have to make whole a safety already on their roster.

All-Pro Minkah Fitzpatrick is scheduled to become a free agent in 2023, and the Pittsburgh Steelers need to do everything in their power to ensure that doesn’t happen.

“The Steelers are going to have to commit some money to Minkah Fitzpatrick,” former NFL executive Randy Mueller told Heavy on Steelers. “So, it’s going to be hard to commit any more money to another safety besides that.”

Mueller believes paying Fitzpatrick, though worth every penny, limits the options at Pittsburgh’s disposal.

“I don’t think they’re going to be in the market for an even medium-priced safety in free agency,” continued Mueller. “I think they’re probably going to have to go younger there and get a guy who can play opposite the skillset that Minkah Fitzpatrick brings. Maybe it’s more of a box safety, maybe it’s more of a physical presence in and around the line of scrimmage. But I think they’re going to have to go younger at the safety position just because of what it’s going to take to sign Minkah long-term.”

The longer Mathieu remains on the free-agent market; the more affordable a contract will become. But if Pittsburgh wants to keep Fitzpatrick happy — which they do — that’s likely where its focus will be.

A strong argument could be made that Fitzpatrick’s production deems him worthy of far more than he’s scheduled to make. Should the Steelers and Fitzpatrick not get a long-term deal hammered out this offseason, he’ll play on the $10.6 million fifth-year option.

Spotrac calculated a market value for Fitzpatrick of four years, $61 million, which averages out to $15.2 million annually.


Unsafe at Safety

The thought of the Pittsburgh Steelers drafting a safety is enough to make my skin crawl. As evidenced by the Senquez Golson (2015), Artie Burns, Sean Davis (2016), Terrell Edmunds (2018) and Justin Layne (2019) selections, Pittsburgh has an underwhelming track record of drafting defensive backs, especially early.

Golson, selected at No. 56 overall, never played a meaningful snap for the Steelers. He suffered injuries in three consecutive training camps (shoulder, 2015; foot, 2016; hamstring, 2017) and was subsequently cut in September 2017.

Burns and Davis, selected in the first and second rounds, never lived up to their draft position. Both have spent their careers bouncing around the NFL.

Though viewed as a bust because of where he was drafted compared to his output, Edmunds, 25, is serviceable considering the team’s otherwise limited affordable options. Depending on the haul after the smoke of draft weekend clears with college free agent signings, Pittsburgh could bring Edmunds back. While he’ll never be a first-round caliber player, Edmunds knows the Steelers’ system and mainly improved as his career progressed.

Edmunds started 60 of 64 games, racking up 340 tackles and five interceptions. A return on a short-term deal would at least provide continuity at a position from which they desperately need production opposite Fitzpatrick.

Comment Here
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x