Josh Downs Trade Grades Roundup: Chiefs Add Explosive Weapon for Patrick Mahomes

We have a roundup of grades from NFL experts on the Kansas City Chiefs' trade acquisition of wide receiver Josh Downs.
Getty
INDIANAPOLIS, INDIANA - NOVEMBER 30: Josh Downs #2 of the Indianapolis Colts catches a pass that was later called back for holding against the Houston Texans during the third quarter at Lucas Oil Stadium on November 30, 2025 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Dylan Buell/Getty Images)

The Kansas City Chiefs‘ offense is getting a big boost for the second half of the season.

Wide receiver Josh Downs was acquired by Kansas City in a trade with the Indianapolis Colts just before the deadline. Downs should get on the field immediately and become a big part of the passing attack. We rounded up several grades from NFL experts across the sports media landscape on the Chiefs’ decision to add Downs to their roster.

Kansas City Chiefs Trade for Josh Downs: ESPN’s Grade- B+

ESPN NFL analyst Seth Walder believes we will see Rashee Rice and Xavier Worthy play out on the boundary more, with Downs working in the slot.

“Both Rashee Rice (35%) and Xavier Worthy (20%) spend time in the slot, but I expect those numbers will drop with Downs, who aligned in the slot 51% of the time in Indianapolis this season, now on the team. Over his career, Rice’s numbers have been slightly worse in the slot (2.3 yards per route run) compared with when he’s lined up outside or elsewhere (2.8).”

Sports Illustrated’s Grade: B+

NFL staff writer Matt Verderame likes the fact that the Chiefs can either lock Downs up to a long-term contract after the season, or recoup a draft pick if they let him walk.

“While Downs isn’t a world-beater, he’s excellent against man coverage and can align outside or in the slot. If the Chiefs sign him to a long-term deal once his contract expires this offseason, the price is terrific. If he walks, Kansas City could scoop up a compensatory pick.”

Bleacher Report’s Grade: A

NFL analyst Moe Moton thinks that Downs and Rice will balance each other out as an impactful duo, and Downs could end up being Kansas City’s top receiver overall.

“Going to Kansas City, Downs can complement Rashee Rice better than inconsistent speedster Xavier Worthy. He’s capable of lining up in the slot and on the perimeter as a versatile playmaker and could emerge as the Chiefs’ most productive receiver.”

CBS Sport’s Grade: B+

Senior NFL writer Zachary Pereles says Downs should provide the Chiefs with their biggest missing ingredient.

“Josh Downs to the Chiefs is one of the best fits of trade season. Downs is a separation machine who beats man coverage in his sleep, adding an element the Chiefs simply didn’t have before. Though he isn’t a deep threat, he does have more intermediate juice than was being realized in a dismal Colts passing game. Kansas City could have added an offensive lineman or a deep threat, but for now, Downs is good work.”

0 Comments

Josh Downs Trade Grades Roundup: Chiefs Add Explosive Weapon for Patrick Mahomes

Notify of
0 Comments
Follow this thread
0
Would love your thoughts, please commentx
()
x