Why Doesn’t ‘Star Trek’ Use Small Fighters?

The Federation Attack Fighter

YouTube The Federation Attack Fighter

In the vast realm of “Star Trek” fandom, many consider “Deep Space Nine” to be the best series of them all. Within DS9, the best season, according to quite a few, is season 6. This is where fans are finally treated to the long-awaited Dominion War, which Ira Stephen Behr and his creative team had been working toward for so many years. 

The penultimate episode during the Dominion War is “Sacrifice of Angels,” where fans got to see a massive ship-to-ship battle featuring the U.S.S. Defiant, commanded by Captain Sisko (Avery Brooks), and dozens of other Federation and Klingon ships face the Dominion and Cardassian fleet. 

From within the Defiant, Sisko ordered the Attack Fighters to strafe the Cardassian ships to force them to leave the formation. Eventually, the Klingon cruisers could break through, allowing the Defiant to cruise to DS9 and win the battle.

Before this battle, the presence of the Federation Attack Fighter was mentioned a few times. Still, they had not played a significant part in many Trek stories. Why is that?


A Small Ship?


Star Trek Starships Collection Federation Attack Fighter Issue 68 ReviewJoin me •• become a patron patreon.com/IrishTrekkie ShuttlePack giveaway — facebook.com/irishtrekkie/posts/521387858042640:0 — twitter.com/theirishtrekkie — facebook.com/irishtrekkie — instagram.com/irishtrekkie 2nd channel — youtube.com/channel/UClDvG-XfwAJUO52xDq424zg — Dublin Comic Con 2015 youtube.com/playlist?list=PLasBav3Dahq2RSI54AmI7-QCYkFQEebai — Star Trek The Official Starships Collection youtube.com/playlist?list=PLasBav3Dahq28Qv6-8BqzVfW8QYAx18_w Star Trek Starships Collection Issue 68 FULL REVIEW This brand new collection of models from the STAR TREK universe which…2016-03-20T19:24:28Z

Some might point to the Defiant as a “small warship,” which is true. The Defiant can’t be considered a fighter since it was 170.68 meters long and could hold 192, according to the “Deep Space Nine Illustrated Handbook.” Fighters like the Federation Attack Fighter, which was somewhat based on the X-Wing from “Star Wars,” could hold no more than two crew. 

Tom Paris’s Delta Flyer also does not quite fit into the “fighter” category. It was categorized as a shuttlecraft with some special modifications. While Paris and Harry Kim did have some adventures on the Delta Flyer, it was never considered a fighter. 


The Empire Doesn’t Consider a Small, One-Man Fighter To Be Any Threat


Trekyards EP178 – Fighters in TrekFighters in Trek…a good idea or not? Lets look at some famous fighters and discuss. Main Website: trekyards.com Other YouTube Channel: Captain Foley's Channel youtube.com/channel/UCUhxafMp1hqNHTQ97H3lCqg Social Media: Main Trekyards Facebook Page: facebook.com/groups/trekyards/ Trekyards Model Building Showcase Facebook Page: facebook.com/groups/525656090901951/ Team Trekyards Star Trek Online Facebook Group: facebook.com/groups/TeamTrekyards/ Star Trek Timelines (Trekyards Facebook Team Page): facebook.com/groups/836643756447057/…2016-09-03T16:00:02Z

Yes, that is a line from “Star Wars,” but perhaps it holds true for “Star Trek” as well. While there have been many Trek episodes featuring small ships — starting back in the TOS era with “The Galileo Seven” — smaller vessels were used for transport and escape, rather than combat. 

Designer Jim Martin created the Attack Fighter and assisted in designing the Defiant. He worked with scenic artist Doug Drexler and designer Herman Zimmerman. Martin also designed the Maquis Raider. When Martin created the Attack Fighter, Drexler said that it looked too much like a “Star Wars” vessel.

“Being a number of years younger than the rest of us, Jim was highly influenced by ‘Star Wars,’ and often that would show in his work,” Drexler noted on his blog. “Nothing gave me more excess stomach acid than that, so I would carry an eleven-foot G-95 cattle prod and used it in case ‘The Force’ clouded his vision.”


Fighters Were No Match for Starships


Soundtrack | Star Trek TNG: Conundrum – "Lysian Perimeter" & "Exposing MacDuff" (OST music+video)Star Trek: The Next Generation soundtracks "Lysian Perimeter" & "Exposing MacDuff" from season 5 episode 14 "Conundrum". Music composed by Dennis McCarthy. Copyright CBS/Paramount Pictures2019-12-27T17:00:03Z

As demonstrated in “The Next Generation” episode “Conundrum,” the Enterprise-D quickly destroyed a small fleet of Lysian fighters without too much trouble. The episode showcased the unmatched power that a modern Federation starship had over small ships. This could have been one of the many possible reasons that writers of Trek chose not to involve smaller ships in significant battles. 

A fan post on the StackExchange SciFi boards explains that the “Roddenberry universe is dominated by weapons, sensors and defensive systems that would generally render ‘fighters’ as we know them useless in battle.”


New Stories Use Smaller Ships


Star Trek: Beyond – Enterprise vs The Swarm2018-04-06T01:38:36Z

Fans familiar with the newer Trek stories, including “Star Trek Beyond,” can attest that small ships certainly can threaten a large vessel. In “Beyond,” Enterprise is literally shredded by a swarm of tiny fighters. Kirk (Chris Pine) orders the ship to fire at will, while Spock (Zachary Quinto) shares that the vessel is not equipped for “this manner of engagement.”

In the season 2 finale of “Star Trek: Discovery,” the Enterprise, commanded by Pike (Anson Mount), and the Discovery, commanded by Commander Saru (Doug Jones), face a fleet of Section 31 ships, both large and small. Among the vessels deployed against the enemy was a Tactical Flyer, which was seen in just this battle. 

In both instances, these small ships proved effective against larger vessels. 


Better Graphics, More Small Ships


The Battle Against Control in Star Trek: Discovery (2017-) (1/2)The Star Trek: Discovery Season 2 finale is very much the second half of a two-parter. If "Part 1" of "Such Sweet Sorrow" was about building the stakes for the epic battle to come, Part II is all about the battle against "Control", Section 31’s artificial intelligence which has emerged to be the main antagonist…2019-05-12T09:45:50Z

It could be that with advanced graphics, “Star Trek” will see smaller vessels in their stories. Knowing that they are not constrained by model makers and designers who are influenced by “Star Wars,” the writers can use the new special effects and designs to create different stories. 

READ NEXT: How Elvis Changed the Life of One ‘Star Trek’ Beauty


Comment Here
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x