
The Indianapolis Colts didn’t trade away Jonathan Taylor despite the incessant rumors, and they still have him under contract through 2028.
But the way they used Seth McGowan on Sunday against the Miami Dolphins, giving the seventh-round rookie 12 carries, suggests a decision might be coming soon on Taylor’s future.
There are actually a couple of ways the Colts could go at the moment, but there are definitely ways to speculate on Taylor based on what McGowan is doing.
And the reality, too, is that McGowan has been really impressive.
ESPN’s Stephen Holder wrote this: “Rookie RB Seth McGowan had a career-high 12 rushes and 77 yards despite Jonathan Taylor being healthy and presumably a member of the team moving forward now that the NFL trade deadline has passed. The usage of McGowan continued a trend toward a heavier workload for the seventh-round pick, who scored a touchdown for the second straight game Sunday.”
Let’s consider what might come next.
Jonathan Taylor Decision Looms

The first truth is that the Colts could still trade Taylor. It just can’t happen until the offseason.
He’d look quite appealing to another team with two years remaining on his deal. The Colts could likely still have a high asking price, and potentially with more bidders since it won’t be in the middle of the season.
So that’s one possible Taylor decision Indy could still make, and if they think that’s possible, it’s totally reasonable for them to want to see what McGowan brings to the table.
The other thing the Colts could choose to do at some point is shut Taylor down. With nothing to play for, Indianapolis wouldn’t want Taylor getting seriously injured late in the year to jeopardize the start of 2027 for him — or to hurt his trade value in the offseason.
If McGowan proves capable week in and week out, it wouldn’t be shocking — for this lost season at least — to see Taylor’s workload continue to shrink.
Colts Schedule
The other thing in play this week in particular is that the Colts knew they were playing on Sunday and will play again Thursday against the Houston Texans to begin Week 11.
Teams often use RBs slightly differently on short weeks, either in the lead-in game or in the Thursday game itself.
Thursday Night Football will provide a lot more information about this backfield. If McGowan again gets similar work to Taylor, that’ll prove that it’s a trend here to stay, and it’ll also increase speculation about what might happen next with JT.
Colts’ Seth McGowan Usage Hints at Jonathan Taylor Decision