11 Best Yogurt Makers: Your Easy Buying Guide

Today’s yogurt makers span many shapes and forms. You’ll find everything from multicookers that can be used to make yogurt, to stand-alone automatic machines to strainer kits that require a minimal amount of storage space. All are easy to use.

Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker, yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Side timer markings
  • Indicator light
  • Clear lid for easy viewing
Price: $39.99 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
Dash Greek Yogurt Maker, yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Compact
  • Lightweight
  • Recipe guide included
Price: $43.50 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
Euro Cuisine YM260 Yogurt Maker, 2-Quart, yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Compact
  • User-friendly design
  • Two-quart capacity
Price: $85.95 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
instant pot Amazon Customer Reviews
  • User-friendly design
  • Ideal for beginners
  • Six-quart capacity
Price: $99.95 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
Cuisinart CYM-100 Electronic Yogurt Maker with Automatic Cooling, yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Stainless steel exterior
  • Time controls
  • Automatic cooling mode
Price: $159.87 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
yogurt machine Amazon Customer Reviews
  • BPA-free container included
  • Digital control panel
  • Countdown timer
Price: $47.74 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
greek yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Basic design
  • Works with Instant Pot cookers
  • Compact
Price: $35.99 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
euro cuisine yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Simple design
  • Yogurt container included
  • Comes with a fine mesh strainer
Price: $34.99 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Clear lid included
  • LED display screen
  • Modern stainless steel housing
Price: $55.99 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
yogurt machine Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Water bath technology
  • Digital control timer
  • Waterproof touch panel
Price: $100.00 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
yogurt maker Amazon Customer Reviews
  • Uniform heating
  • Reduced power consumption
  • Built-in timer
Price: $32.99 Shop at Amazon Shop now Read our review
Our Unbiased Reviews
  1. 1. Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker (YM80)

    • Makes yogurt in 6 to 10 hours
    • 42-ounce capacity
    • Can control ingredients, fat content and more
    • Doesn’t come with a thermometer
    • Lids can leak
    • No auto shutoff

    You can make your favorite yogurt in just six to 10 hours depending on the desired thickness. Aside from producing all-natural creamy and rich yogurt, you can control the thickness, sweetness, ingredients and fat content. It’s possible to make up to 42 ounces of yogurt at once. As an added bonus this yogurt maker comes with multiple six-ounce glass jars with lids so that you can treat yourself with different flavors as desired.

    A timer on the side of the appliance gives you a better idea of when the yogurt will be finished. Other highlights include a clear lid to let you monitor your yogurt’s process along with an on/off switch for added convenience.

  2. 2. Dash Greek Yogurt Maker

    • Two-quart capacity
    • BPA-free buckets with lids
    • Quick start dial
    • Relatively small capacity
    • Consumers must heat up the milk first then transfer it into the container
    • No audible alert when yogurt is done

    This yogurt maker features a generous two-quart capacity. It also includes two BPA-free buckets with a 1.5 quart capacity per each bucket. Both buckets also include a lid and a Greek strainer.

    This yogurt maker is outfitted with a convenient LCD display with a custom timer to help you keep track of the yogurt as it cooks. Another highlight is hidden cord storage for added convenience.

    All you need to get started is your favorite type of milk and a bit of store-bought yogurt. The product also comes with a comprehensive recipe guide with a quick start dial. This yogurt maker lets you whip up your favorite flavors of Greek yogurt.

  3. 3. Euro Cuisine Yogurt Maker (YM260)

    • Comes with several accessories
    • Can make yogurt with any type of milk
    • Includes cotton bag for making Greek yogurt and cheese
    • Flimsy plastic components
    • Timer isn’t automatic
    • Container can be tough to remove when full

    This yogurt maker lets you prepare up to 2 quarts of yogurt in 6 to 8 hours. You don’t have to limit yourself to whole milk in order to get delicious results as you can create rich, creamy, delicious yogurt using just about any type of milk, including soy. As an added bonus you can also use the included cotton bag to make Greek yogurt and cheese.

    Highlights include a stainless steel thermostat that lets you keep close track of the yogurt’s temperature and a timer that informs you when the yogurt’s done. Safety-conscious consumers will appreciate the BPA-free yogurt container.

  4. 4. Instant Pot Duo Nova

    • Replaces seven popular appliances
    • Comes with a yogurt-making setting
    • Large digital display
    • No diffused steam release
    • Lacks smartphone control
    • Doesn't have interior pot handles

    The Instant Pot Duo Nova is a multicooker that has a specific setting for making yogurt. This convenient device replaces seven popular appliances in one and can be used to steam, saute, cook rice, slow cook, pressure cook and more. Even beginners can quickly figure out how to make a batch thanks to the device’s user-friendly design, which simply involves adding the ingredients then pushing the desired button.

    A six-quart capacity ensures plenty of cooking and storage space for each batch. If you could use some inspiration, browse available recipes on your iOS or Android device.

  5. 5. Cuisinart Electronic Yogurt Maker

    • 50-ounce capacity
    • Simple one-touch operation
    • Crisp LED display
    • Can’t control the temperature
    • Overall capacity is a bit small
    • Plastic material seems flimsy

    All you have to do is sit back and wait for this machine to produce up to 50 ounces of your favorite milk or soy milk-based yogurt. A handy built-in cooling system automatically changes to the ideal chilling temperature when the yogurt is done.

    Other features include a simple operation that begins and ends with the push of a button and time controls that make it easy to set the suggested fermenting time. You can make over six 8-ounce servings of yogurt at once with the large yogurt container.

    An LED display clearly shows the cooking time and automatically counts down. To get started simply mix your desired ingredients together then pour them into the yogurt container.

  6. 6. Proctor Silex Yogurt Maker

    • Modern stainless steel exterior
    • Comes with a recipe guide
    • Holds up to 32 ounces per batch
    • Can be tricky to lift container out once it's in the machine
    • Display isn't backlit
    • Plastic lid clips seem flimsy

    This digital yogurt maker gives you full control over each batch, so you can determine everything from the amount of sugar that goes into the yogurt to incorporating your preferred toppings. The yogurt maker whips up batches without the use of a strainer. A large digital display shows how much longer you have to wait until you can enjoy that freshly made batch.

    This machine comes with a 32-ounce BPA-free storage container. For your convenience, the container can be washed by hand or placed in the dishwasher. An included recipe guide provides tips and inspiration for your next batch. A modern stainless steel exterior makes this yogurt maker an attractive appliance for any kitchen.

  7. 7. Hatrigo Greek Yogurt Maker

    • Comes with a space-saving container
    • One-gallon strainer is included
    • Ideal for anyone who doesn't want an automatic yogurt maker
    • Strainer isn't dishwasher safe
    • Can be tricky to clean by hand
    • Some yogurt might seep through when straining

    Simplicity is the hallmark feature of this yogurt maker, with a one-gallon strainer and a container that’s compact enough to store in the fridge. The yogurt maker is also a favorite Instant Pot accessory among enthusiasts. You can choose to pair the yogurt maker with your Instant Pot machine or use it independently.

    If you’re using it on its own, this yogurt maker is a solid choice for whipping up batches of cold start yogurt or your favorite yogurt in jars.

  8. 8. Euro Cuisine Greek Yogurt Maker (GY60)

    • Sealing lid keeps contents secure
    • Holds up to two quarts per batch
    • Measurement markings in cups and ounces on the side
    • Hand washing recommended for the strainer
    • Mesh strainer can sag a bit when full
    • Some say it doesn't quite hold a gallon of yogurt

    Consider this Greek yogurt maker if you value simplicity. The no-frills yogurt maker comes with just a few parts, including an acrylic container and a fine mesh yogurt strainer. A sealing lid keeps contents from leaking out and doubles as a serving lid when necessary. The yogurt maker holds up to two quarts of thick Greek yogurt per batch.

    If you want to customize your current batch, you can add toppings such as berries or nuts for even more delicious end results. Measurement markings are provided in cups and ounces on the side of the container to help you keep track.

  9. 9. Homeleader Yogurt Maker

    • Eight food-grade jars are included
    • Yogurt is held at a constant cooking temperature
    • Makes a batch in six to nine hours
    • Vague instruction manual
    • Low-quality glass jars
    • Some competitors are faster at making a batch

    This yogurt maker by Homeleader does the hard work for you thanks to its innovative temperature system, which prepares the yogurt at the most ideal temperature. As it cooks, the yogurt is held at a constant temperature to ensure optimal results. Eight food-grade jars are included to store the yogurt when it’s done.

    If you’re looking for a bit more variety, you can customize each batch or simply add your favorite toppings or ingredients to customize each jar. You can set the timer and keep tabs on how much time is left on the LED display screen. Stainless steel housing gives this yogurt maker a modern appearance.

  10. 10. Luvele Pure Yogurt Maker

    • Comes with four ceramic jars
    • Choice between three temperature settings
    • Total capacity is 1.5 liters
    • Control panel temperature only displayed in Celsius
    • Jar lids can be tough to remove
    • Takes awhile to make a batch

    As with sous vide cooking, the Luvele yogurt maker relies on water bath technology for optimal results. As the yogurt cooks in the water bath, the temperatures remain accurate and consistent during the incubation process. A 24-hour digital timer makes it easier to keep track of each batch as it cooks.

    This yogurt maker is equipped with a 24-hour digital control timer for added convenience. You can also choose between three temperature settings (in Celsius) for more personalized results. Other highlights include a waterproof touch panel and an automatic off switch. The yogurt maker comes with four ceramic jars for a total storage capacity of 1.5 liters.

  11. 11. MVPower Automatic Digital Yogurt Machine

    • Only uses 25 watts per batch
    • Microcomputer timer appropriately times each batch
    • Comes with eight six-ounce jars
    • Some complain of inaccurate temperatures
    • Takes a long time to make each batch
    • Buttons aren't very intuitive

    Uneven heating can lead to subpar results, which is why this yogurt maker stands out for its uniform heating. Another perk is that it cooks over a longer period of time to reduce power consumption. In fact, the yogurt cooks at just 25 watts for 48 hours to help reduce your energy cost. The timer is set for 48 hours, which allows the batch to fully cook and incubate before it’s ready for consumption.

    A microcomputer timer ensures each batch is appropriately timed. This yogurt maker comes with eight jars, each of which stores up to six ounces of yogurt.

Is Yogurt Healthy?

Yogurt is a healthy and versatile source of vital nutrients, including calcium and protein. However, it may offer even more health benefits. According to the Harvard School of Public Health, one study over the course of 20 years demonstrated that yogurt consumption helped to protect against weight gain. Additionally, eating yogurt every day could offer protection against type 2 diabetes and heart disease.

How Do You Make Yogurt?

The most popular base for yogurt is milk, although you can certainly use your favorite alternatives. According to Cultures For Health, the proteins in cow milk coagulate during the heating process, which ultimately produces a thicker yogurt compared to raw or unheated milk.

The same source reveals that while non-dairy milk products will work, their cultures don't survive for long, which means that you need to use a new starter for every batch. Non-dairy milk without preservatives or additives works best.

If lactose intolerance is a concern, here's some potentially good news from the Dairy Council of California. Unless you are severely lactose intolerant, you can probably still enjoy your own homemade yogurt. That's because yogurt doesn't have as much lactose as milk, as the lactose is converted to lactic acid.

Can You Make Yogurt in a Crockpot?

An increasing number of crockpots and multi-cookers can make yogurt. We've highlighted the Instant Pot Duo Nova, which is beginner-friendly and can specifically used to make yogurt. In most cases, you simply add the ingredients and start the process with the push of a button.  You can also check out a larger selection of electric pressure cookers that make yogurt.

See Also:

Disclaimer: Heavy Inc. is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and other affiliate advertising programs and may receive a commission if you purchase a product via a link on this page.

Read More
, ,