Giants QB J.J. McCarthy Predicted as Starter for AFC Team in 2027

J.J. McCarthy
Getty
New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy.

It used to be that if you were an NFL quarterback, a 1st-round pick, and you failed with the team that drafted you, that was usually the end of the road.

There wasn’t a second life or a second chance to reboot with another team. You were just cooked.

Turns out, giving up on talented players wasn’t the best move, and the last few years have seen the rise of the “reclamation project QB” — a group led by Super Bowl winner Sam Darnold with the Seattle Seahawks that includes Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield as well.

Bleacher Report’s Brent Sobleski thinks New York Giants starting quarterback J.J. McCarthy could be the next name to reclaim his career with another team after the Minnesota Vikings drafted him in the 1st round (No. 10 overall) of the 2024 NFL Draft but cut bait early this season, sending him to the Giants in exchange for a 5th-round pick.

McCarthy has shown he’s more than a competent starter for the Giants, going 2-1 in his first three starts—and Sobleski thinks he could be the perfect fit for an AFC team that will have an opening at quarterback in 2027: the Pittsburgh Steelers.


Steelers Primed for Post-Aaron Rodgers Era

The Steelers know they’ll need a new quarterback in 2027, with 42-year-old quarterback and 4-time NFL MVP Aaron Rodgers already having said this will be his 22nd and final season.

For the Giants, their future still lies with 2025 1st-round pick Jaxson Dart, who suffered a season-ending knee injury in a Week 2 loss to the Los Angeles Rams.

“For now, Dart remains the presumed long-term preference in New York,” Sobleski wrote on Tuesday. “The Giants only traded a 2027 fifth-round draft pick to obtain McCarthy’s services. The team’s front office could easily profit by flipping the quarterback next offseason. As of now, Pittsburgh owns extra third-, sixth- and seventh-round picks, as well as five of its original selections, for next year’s draft. Pittsburgh doesn’t operate in a fashion where a full-blown rebuild is expected. As such, a top quarterback prospect almost certainly won’t be available through the draft. Instead, the Steelers should fill their quarterback room with talented, young individuals and allow one to emerge as QB1.”


McCarthy Could Create QB Controversy in NY

There’s little doubt that if McCarthy continues to be the steady presence he’s been for the Giants so far, a full-blown quarterback controversy will head to New York in 2027.

While Dart has shown a lot of promise, the Giants choosing him over McCarthy — if he can finish things off and get the Giants into the playoffs — might actually be the second option.

What wouldn’t behoove the team or either player would be some type of training-camp battle where they duke it out like they’re on a small-town high school football team. If McCarthy puts the Giants in the playoffs, he seems like the clear-cut starter, and in that case Dart might be the one on the move via a trade.

0 Comments

Giants QB J.J. McCarthy Predicted as Starter for AFC Team in 2027

Notify of
0 Comments
Follow this thread
0
Would love your thoughts, please commentx
()
x