NFL Experts Weigh in on Colts’ Chances to Win AFC South, Super Bowl

Frank Reich

Getty NFL analysts and experts predicted where the Indianapolis Colts will finish during the 2022 season.

The Indianapolis Colts haven’t won a division title since the 2014 season and have gone 13 years without a Super Bowl appearance.

But with the regular season quickly approaching NFL analysts and experts at The Athletic and released their final projections for the 2022 season. About three-quarters of the experts at The Athletic predicted the Colts to win the AFC South.

Furthermore, the Colts were one of just eight teams picked to win the Super Bowl by analysts at

ALL the latest Colts news straight to your inbox! Join the Heavy on Colts newsletter here!

Join Heavy on Colts!

Colts Predicted to Win AFC South

A total of 43 experts from The Athletic predicted the winner of all eight NFL divisions. Of those 43 experts, 32 of them (74.4%) picked the Colts to win the AFC South.

“Our experts are big believers in Matt Ryan and Indianapolis’ ability to revive itself after losing to the Jaguars in the last game of the regular season and missing out on a playoff spot,” The Athletic NFL staff wrote. “The Colts were one of the most unlucky teams last year in the NFL. They had the seventh-best point differential but somehow only won nine games. That could be explained by losing five of their seven one-score games in 2021.”

The other 11 experts all picked the Tennessee Titans to win the division. The Jacksonville Jaguars and Houston Texans did not receive any votes.

“Tennessee went 6-2 in one-score games last year, and that’s after finishing 7-2 in one-score games in 2020. That’s an impressive record, but will it keep up? Teams usually regress to the mean in one-score games, and this might be the year the Titans’ luck runs out.

“The Athletic’s NFL model gives the Colts a 64.1% chance to win the division while the Titans sit at 30.1. The Jaguars and Texans combine for less than a 6% chance.”

The only AFC team with more experts from The Athletic predicting them to win their division was the Buffalo Bills. The Bills were the unanimous choice to win the AFC East.

In the NFC, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers were also a unanimous choice to win their division. Other than the Bills and Buccaneers, only the Green Bay Packers and Los Angeles Rams received more votes to win their division than the Colts.

Colts Among Teams Picked to Win Super Bowl

The experts at The Athletic and analysts at are in near agreement. Of the 25 analysts who picked a Super Bowl winner, 12 of them selected the Bills and three of them chose the Buccaneers.

The Los Angeles Chargers were the only other team with multiple analysts picking them to win the Super Bowl. The Chargers received five votes, which was second only to the Bills.

While Indianapolis didn’t get multiple votes like those three teams, the Colts were one of five teams to receive one vote to win the Super Bowl.

“Matt Ryan breathes life into Indy’s passing game and exorcises Super Bowl demons while the Colts’ defensive front swarms the Rams for a convincing title triumph,” wrote NFL analyst Lance Zierlein.

The other teams that received one vote to win the Super Bowl along with the Colts were the Packers, Baltimore Ravens, Kansas City Chiefs and Philadelphia Eagles.

Read More