Payton Tolle: Everything you need to know

Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle

#70 SP

Status

ACTIVE

STATS

Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle Game Log   2026

  • Preseason
     
    Date
    Opp
    Result
    IP
    K
    BB
    HBP
    CG
    SHO
    H
    R
    ER
    2/26
    W 7-5
    1.2
    0
    0
    2
    0
    0
    3
    2
    2
    2/21
    W 7-2
    2.0
    1
    0
    0
    0
    0
    1
    1
    1
Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle Player Profile  

Birthdate 11/1/2002 (23)
Status MIN
HT/WT 6'6", 250 lbs
Draft Info 2024: Rd 2; Pk 11 (BOS)
Birthplace Stillwater, OK, USA
Position SP
College TCU

Career History

Boston Red Sox 2025-Present (2 seasons)

Payton Tolle: Breaking News

Racks up 11 punchouts in 2026 debut

Tolle allowed one run on three hits and one walk while striking out 11 batters over six innings in a no-decision against the Yankees on Thursday. Tolle looked dominant against a tough Yankees lineup, racking up 18 swinging strikes and a career-high 11 punchouts. The southpaw gave up a solo homer to Jazz Chisholm in the fifth inning, but the Yankees managed just two other hits (both singles) against him. Tolle was called up Thursday to take the rotation spot of Sonny Gray, who is on the injured list with a hamstring issue. With Gray slated to miss about two more weeks, at minimum, Tolle should get an opportunity to make additional starts for the big-league club. If he's anywhere near as effective as he was Thursday, the Red Sox may have no choice but to keep Tolle in the rotation long-term.

Officially recalled ahead of start

The Red Sox recalled Tolle from Triple-A Worcester on Thursday, Chris Cotillo of MassLive.com reports. Tolle will start Thursday's game against the rival Yankees in place of the injured Sonny Gray (hamstring). The left-hander has logged a 3.00 ERA, 1.07 WHIP and 19:4 K:BB across 15 innings in his first three starts for Worcester this season. There's a good chance Tolle will get an additional start or two for the Red Sox while Gray recuperates.

Starting Thursday

The Red Sox will recall Tolle from Triple-A Worcester to start Thursday's game against the Yankees, Ian Browne of MLB.com reports. It seemed like Tolle would be the choice to fill in for the injured Sonny Gray (hamstring) when the former had his start skipped at Worcester over the weekend, and the decision has now been confirmed. Tolle made seven appearances (three starts) in the big leagues last season but struggled to the tune of a 6.06 ERA and 1.59 WHIP across 16.1 innings. He seems to have bounced back nicely in Triple-A this year, logging a 3.00 ERA and 1.07 WHIP through 15 frames, so he'll get another chance to show what he can do in The Show. If he performs well, he'll likely remain with the Red Sox until Gray returns from the IL.

Payton Tolle: More News

Red Sox Rookie Payton Tolle Makes History in Dominant Debut vs. Yankees

Red Sox Rookie Payton Tolle Makes History in Dominant Debut vs. Yankees

Red Sox May Already Have Scapegoat Amid Early Struggles

Red Sox May Already Have Scapegoat Amid Early Struggles

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Has Blunt Answer After Being Swept By the Yankees

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Has Blunt Answer After Being Swept By the Yankees

Red Sox Get New Jarren Duran Trade Take As Boston’s Struggles Continue

Red Sox Get New Jarren Duran Trade Take As Boston’s Struggles Continue

Red Sox Get Major Triston Casas News Amid Losing Streak

Red Sox Get Major Triston Casas News Amid Losing Streak

Roman Anthony Injury Update: Latest News on Red Sox Star’s Status

Roman Anthony Injury Update: Latest News on Red Sox Star’s Status

Boston Red Sox Announce Payton Tolle Roster Decision Before Yankees Game

Boston Red Sox Announce Payton Tolle Roster Decision Before Yankees Game

Red Sox Coach Reveals Bad Roman Anthony Injury Update

Red Sox Coach Reveals Bad Roman Anthony Injury Update

Boston Red Sox Outfielder Jarren Duran Delivers a Clear Message Following Yankees Loss

Boston Red Sox Outfielder Jarren Duran Delivers a Clear Message Following Yankees Loss

Red Sox Get Major Rotation News Before Yankees Series Finale

Red Sox Get Major Rotation News Before Yankees Series Finale

Struggling Boston Red Sox Player Still Owed Over $50 Million By The Team

Struggling Boston Red Sox Player Still Owed Over $50 Million By The Team

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Makes Honest Statement After Yankees Game

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Makes Honest Statement After Yankees Game

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Announce Roman Anthony Decision Before Yankees Game

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Announce Roman Anthony Decision Before Yankees Game

MLB Insider Takes Clear Stance on Red Sox Firing Alex Cora

MLB Insider Takes Clear Stance on Red Sox Firing Alex Cora

2026 Boston Marathon Winners, Bravo Stars, and Celebrities Pack Fenway During Red Sox Opening Month

2026 Boston Marathon Winners, Bravo Stars, and Celebrities Pack Fenway During Red Sox Opening Month

Red Sox’s Alex Cora Explains Decision to Bench Jarren Duran Against Yankees

Red Sox’s Alex Cora Explains Decision to Bench Jarren Duran Against Yankees

Red Sox Update: Will Payton Tolle Join the Rotation?

Red Sox Update: Will Payton Tolle Join the Rotation?

Yankees’ Cam Schlittler Sends Strong Message to Red Sox Fans

Yankees’ Cam Schlittler Sends Strong Message to Red Sox Fans

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Make Surprising Roster Move After Yankees Game

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Make Surprising Roster Move After Yankees Game

Red Sox Asked Who Could Run a Marathon — Jarren Duran’s Answer Stole the Show

Red Sox Asked Who Could Run a Marathon — Jarren Duran’s Answer Stole the Show

Mookie Betts, Chris Sale Revisit 2018 Red Sox — ‘We Beat the Brakes Off Everybody’

Mookie Betts, Chris Sale Revisit 2018 Red Sox — ‘We Beat the Brakes Off Everybody’

Boston Red Sox Predicted to Trade Controversial Outfielder for Phillies’ Andrew Painter

Boston Red Sox Predicted to Trade Controversial Outfielder for Phillies’ Andrew Painter

Red Sox Place Starting Pitcher On 15-Day IL Before Yankees Game

Red Sox Place Starting Pitcher On 15-Day IL Before Yankees Game

Boston Red Sox Announce Jarren Duran Decision Before Yankees Game

Boston Red Sox Announce Jarren Duran Decision Before Yankees Game

Red Sox Put on Notice for Crucial Alex Bregman Mistake

Red Sox Put on Notice for Crucial Alex Bregman Mistake

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Reportedly Make Roster Move Before Yankees Game

UPDATE: Boston Red Sox Reportedly Make Roster Move Before Yankees Game

Red Sox’s Cora Explains Struggles of Former All-Star

Red Sox’s Cora Explains Struggles of Former All-Star

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Drops Clear Message Ahead of Yankees Series

Boston Red Sox Manager Alex Cora Drops Clear Message Ahead of Yankees Series

Sonny Gray Injury: Who Will Replace Red Sox Starter in Rotation?

Sonny Gray Injury: Who Will Replace Red Sox Starter in Rotation?

Boston Red Sox Announce Worrying Sonny Gray Update as Yankees Series Looms

Boston Red Sox Announce Worrying Sonny Gray Update as Yankees Series Looms

Payton Tolle: More News